Feed on
Posts
comments

Multimedia Projects comparison

 

Le Figaro

Radio-Canada

Presentation

Le Figaro proposes, for the fall of Berlin wall 20th anniversary, a multimedia project. To commemorate this event, we can break the wall ourselves on line. The idea is that behind each part of the wall, there is a story or an animation …

Radio Canada presents a multimedia project about Tar Sands. Actually, I will use this project for my class project. Like in the Figaro, behind each pictures is a special category or subject regarding tar sands.

Style of narration and content

The style is more professional. There is also a pedagogical side, but it’s different from Radio Canada. RC seems to target a child audience, or a wide public, but Le Figaro target a more intellectual audience, and provide precise information (like in the timeline). You can read real articles, with a journalistic content. There is a lot of articles, which presents different sides of the subject, such as culture, history, news …

Throughout the project, you can find plenty of hyperlinks.

The style is very oral and quite familiar. That could be obvious, given that Radio Canada isn’t a print media. The sentences are very short, and written is a very pedagogic style. The journalist seems to write for children. Each statement is illustrated by a photo. As a matter of fact, the content is quite poor. There is not a lot of data, and where there is, they are badly used.

This is an example, the data is interesting, but could be more precise.

At the end of the project, you can find a page with hyperlinks, and there is also hyperlinks throughout the project.

Entertainment

The first page, with the wall we can break is really well done. The sound is quite bothering, but it’s a good idea to try to use sound. The structure of the page is not really good, I mean the texts are presented as common articles of the Figaro, so no color etc. like in RC project.

It’s obvious that the pictures are very well used in this project. There is a lot of pictures, for each quote you can see a picture of the person talking. The pages are very well constructed, colorful, with a graphic hierarchy (quotes are in italic, data in black …)

 Besides, I have to notice that the introduction is really good, it give us the want to read the project.

 

Effectiveness of multimedia

The Vuvox timeline is really well done. There is some videos included in the timeline, which is quite impressive, and very useful.

We can also a find a slideshow, very well done, of interesting photos, which all have a caption (they don’t in the RC project).

But, here again, there is a lack of sound. The interview, the testimony, we want to hear them.

The same thing is also true for the pictures, we want to see the movement, a still photo to explain the fall of the wall it’s not enough. There was a lot of turmoil on that night, we want to see it.

What is quite surprising for a media like Radio Canada is that there is a lack of sound and of video. Indeed, there is only one video , which is interesting, because it explains a process, but it’s not enough.

We can notice that there is also a map to locate the Alberta tar sands exploitations. The pictures are useful. All the statements are illustrated. But it’s not enough. As I said, we want to see more videos, we want to ear some quotations. If the photos are good, they are not always interesting  . We need a slideshow, or a soundslides.

Tools used

We can see the journalists used vuvox for the timeline and the slideshows,

I have no idea of what tool they used to do the entire presentation, probably flash player. But I think there is no other tool used, and they should have.

Ease of navigation

The big problem of this presentation is the navigation. When you click on a part of the wall, you open another page, it’s bothering, and it’s long to load.

The navigation is quite easy, you just need to click on the little arrow, or we have the menu on the top of the page. Besides, the pages are not too long to load.

To conclude, I’m quite impressed by the Figaro project. Firstly, I thought that the RC project was more interesting, more constructed, but when I started to analyze them, I have to say that the Figaro is amazing. I mean, it’s a French media, and our medias have a lot of problem to face, especially with the rise of those new multimedia. Usually, French media are really bad with those projects and with multimedia tools, but there, I can see a real improvement. The Figaro project is much more a complete file about a subject than a project. I’m disappointed by the RC project, I wanted to use it for my final project, but I guess I will have to do more research because this project is really poor.

Tools comparison

 

 

Photofiltre Studio

Photoshop CSA

PROS

- Photofiltre is really easy to use, they are layers as in Photoshop, but you can’t use them in the same way. With Photofiltre, you only are able to change the order of the layers, so to modify your image composition, or to do some really simple stuff.

- Layers allowed me to work on one element of an image without disturbing the others. I could change the composition of my image by changing the order and attributes of layers. Besides, you can use special features such as fill layers, and layer styles …

Besides, you have plenty of applications, tools, effects, filtres …

 

- Now, I want to focus on a special tool, the Clone Stamp Tool. With Photofiltre, it’s very, very easy to use. You can see it on the pictures, I was able to make the girl disappear in 5 minutes.

- I could lighten or darken an area in a photo (you can see it on the baby picture)

CONS

 

 

 

- The layers you have in Photofiltre are only a composition tool, for example in the witche’s picture, if I wanted to add some flowers, I could. And then I could have changed the color/contrast … of that particular element, but I cannot use layer as in Photoshop to work on a specific area.

Besides, the tools, effects, filtre, textures are more limited that in Photoshop.

- Because of all those layers, effect … Photoshop is really hard to use. You can spend your entire life learning to work with it.

 

- I was not able to contrast a special area on the picture, as I could do on Photoshop, so I had to increase the contrast of all the picture.

- The Photoshop Clone Stamp Tool is very precise, but it’s too difficult to use. When you use this tool, generally it creates a new layer, but because the tool is precise, you will only use it if you need to clone a precise thing, like a eye, or a earing … And you will prefer Photofiltre if you only need to make an element disappear.

CONCLUSION

To conclude, we can say that Photoshop CS4 is really more professional than Photofiltre. But, it’s also more difficult to use. I think that the two programs are necessary, because when you want to “doctor” a picture rapidly, use Photofiltre, if you really need a special tool, to do a precise correction, you will use Photoshop. That is to say, Photofiltre is for a quotidian use, whereas Photofiltre is for a professional use. As blogger journalist, I think Photofiltre is really enough, and even as photojournalist, if you have to work every day on a photo, you would prefer Photofiltre.

 photofiltre studioPhotoshop CS4

The Festival du Monde Arabe (FMA) opened its door the 30 October in Montreal for its 10th Edition. This year, the artistic productions will be about the theme « Memoires Croisées », for a real meeting between arabic and quebec culture.

Joseph Nakhlé, who is the President of the Centre Canadien pour l’échange culturel, explained the origin of the Festival :

Le Festival du Monde Arabe 

Pictures from Frédéric Faddoul, and from the website of Ethereal Tribal dance troupe

PS : Actually, I read that it’s impossible to to embed videos in a video player, we had to upload to a video hosting website and add them to your post using their HTML embed code. And I don’t have any youtube or Vimeo account.

PS 2 : I realized with this assignement that it’s much more interesting to listen an interview where there is pictures.

Final Project Update

  1. My topic is about tar sands. But because it’s a very newsworthy subject, all medias are speaking about it. So I need a special angle.
  2. My story will be about a guy who went to Alberta to protest against tar sands. I want to explain his trip, his ideas, why he did that … He is a greenpeace militant.
  3. I can’t name him for now, because I’m not sure I will speak with him particularly, as Greepeace proposed me to speak with other militants. I will also speak with a spokesperson who will explain me more basic stuff about tar sands.
  4. I will use a google map to show where are located the main tar sands’ exploitation. I’m not sure of what tool I will use, I wanted to use Google Map, but I need to find something to point an entire area and not just a little point. Besides, I thought Google Earth should be more effective.
  5. To illustrate the interviewee story, I will post some videos that are available on Greenpeace website. I had the authorization to use them.
  6. I also think to do a slideshow with the interviewee voice as a sound. Photos are also availables on Greenpeace website.
  7. First, I wanted to plot a graph. But I changed my mind, I think it will be useless, because the story is really about how a militant of Greenpeace could change the world, especially before Copenhague. So photos and videos are more usefull.

The Festival du Monde Arabe (FMA) opened its door the 30 October in Montreal for its 10th Edition. This year, the artistic productions will be about the theme « Memoires Croisées », for a real meeting between arabic and quebec culture.

  

The Hanging Gardens of Furat Qaddouri, 5 November 2009

The Hanging Gardens of Furat Qaddouri, 5 November 2009

 Joseph Nakhlé, who is the President of the Centre Canadien pour l’échange culturel, explained the origin of the Festival : « The FMA has been created because it met the need of every human being who belongs to two divergent and opponent cultures ». The FMA originates from the experience of any immigrant arriving in a country with a different culture.

 According to Joseph Nakhlé, who is also the Director of the Festival, the mission of the FMA is to create an intercultural meeting’s spot. To his mind, the Festival is not a tool to promote arabic culture, or a mean to encourage integration among arabic people. Open-mindness is the key word.

  Interview de Joseph Nakhlé

Moreover, the 83% of FMA’s public is Quebecker. Yet, the Festival underwent hard times, with two major crisis. In 2007, the FMA suffered from a drop of 76% of its Quebecker public. But the Director asserted that in 2009 things are getting back to normal.

This year, under the direction of Sean Dagher and Fadi Akiki, the FMA proposes the show « Je me souviens » (I remember), which is an unique experience of the fusion of Quebec’s jig and Middle East’s dabké for an extraordinary meeting of the two cultures.

Quebec could be an example for the other countries. For Joseph Nakhlé, Quebec is today the only country where a real cultural exchange could happen. This statement is at the core of the “Espace Quebec-Monde Arabe” project launched by the Centre Canadien pour l’échange culturel.

Interview Joseph Nakhlé 2

The city of Salem, Massachusetts, is the Halloween capital of the world. People come from around the country and oversea to see the Witches’ City. The city is above all known for the hysteria of the witch burnings which happened nearly 300 years ago.

 

But that hasn’t always been the case. “ Salem has been popular since 1978. Everybody is coming to Salem for Halloween, but it’s more like a Carnival”, the mother of the Witches Cottage’s owner, Pauline Jean said. “Halloween is the best day of the years for us, and for all the restaurants and shops of Salem” she added. To enter a shop, people had to queue more than twenty minutes. And all the parkings of the City, which increased their prices to $20 for all the day, were full by 10 o’clock in the morning.

 

The web is in a huge part responsible of this popularity, according to Salem Police. As a consequence Haunted Happenings have grown “exponentially over the last five, six years,” said Salem Capt. Brian Gilligan to the Salem Gazette.

 

According to Police Chief Paul Tucker, over 100, 000 people take to the streets in costumes throughout the day on Saturday, for the biggest Halloween party on the planet. “It was generally a well-behaved crowd,” said Mayor Kim Driscoll to the Salem News.

sorciere portrait

An old witch staid sat at the bottom of this tree all the day to see the Halloween Carnival

 

The streets were crowded of pointy hats and frightening zombies. On Saturday, Essex street seemed to be Harry Potter’s Diagon Alley. Besides, along the street, plenty of real witchcraft shops proposed to customer tarot readings and spell-casting. And while you are strolling around the streets, suddenly, a couple of puritans turns up in the street and accuse a poor woman of witchcraft. You can follow the arrested witch to the Town Hall and attend her trial. The show, called “Cry Innocent”, is a reconstitution of Bridget Bishop’s famous trial.

ancienne

A puritan women being accused of witchcraft in the streets of Salem

 

But most of the city’s witch-related attractions, while unmistakably amusing, are more fair’s attractions than museums. You can find haunted houses, witches’ cottage and dungeon, but you’ll pay for an entertaining show and not for history.

 

However, not far from the crowded streets, a strange ceremony is happening. To see the real witches of Salem, you should have been to Gallows Hill Park, where the 1692 witches were hung. There, hundreds of people gathered for Samhain Magick Circle. Samhain is the name of Halloween for the pagans. In that particular day, they celebrate the New Year. By chanting and dancing to the rhythm of drums, they honor ancestor and loved one who have gone. Everybody holds hands to do a circle dancing and pass trough an arch which symbolize the New Year. As the ceremony is finished, the assistance begin the “ Commemorative Candlelight Walk ” to the City of Salem’s Witchcraft Memorial.

 

As you can read, real witches still exist in Salem, and they always make sure that the city is protected and blessed in that night of Samhain.

sorciere

A witche leant back on a shop frontdoor the morning after Halloween

 

 

Lexis Nexis Excercises

1. et 2. : documents perdus en class parce que bug de l’ordinateur.

3. Bombardier :

sold Bombardier Recreational Products, snowmobile division, in 2003, because of a restructuring plan and because of a net loss.

http://www.lexis.com/research/retrieve?_m=fe3a1bf472c4f33375672c40c339ff62&csvc=bl&cform=searchForm&_fmtstr=FULL&docnum=1&_startdoc=1&wchp=dGLzVzz-zSkAA&_md5=832fc6dc84a38f88d9230304877aaadc

SECTION: BUSINESS; Pg. B01

1

Basically, this graph deals with juvenile delinquency. We have a series of crime, like homicide, sexual assault, drugs and weapons possession … This graph allows us to understand rapidly which are the main trends in juvenile delinquency, that it to say, essentially theft. The second thing is that we can see the progression of each crime among youth during three years. For example, we see that the thefts decreased between 2004/2005 and 2005/2006, but stagnated between 2005/2006 and 2006/2007. That is also the case for common assaults and weapons possessions. The sexual assaults decreased, but the possession of drugs nearly edged up to 1, 000 cases. I think this graph is interesting because he goes against all preconceived notions which state that juvenile delinquency is growing. It’s not the case when we see the statistics. But, this graph is also newsworthy because the juvenile delinquency is always a big problem today. Actually, those statistics help us to figure out what kind of crime young people usually commit.

Ecole polytechnique de Montreal, le 6 décembre 1989

Ecole polytechnique de Montreal, le 6 décembre 1989

This article about Guns and Youth crime is really interesting for two things. On the first hand, it shows that youth crime is a serious debate in our society. We know that Canadian people are shell-shocked by weapon possession among young people; “the killing of 14 women at the Ecole Polytechnique in December 1989, and the shooting spree at Dawson College in September 2006”, is always in Canadian minds. My graph shows that weapon possessions are stagnating from 2004 until today. This article is written in 2008. So the journalist should have check statistics, and write about those figures, to explain that this problem is not really increasing. Yet, my graph doesn’t show the guns possession figures among weapons possessions. Therefore, on the second hand, this article proves that every graph has to be explained and put into perspective by other data. Indeed, we well see that the weapon possessions cases are not growing, but we have to precise that this figure is really high, for example by comparing it with the weapons possessions cases among adults.

The second article about Youth crime prevention in Ottawa suffers from a lack of figures. Indeed, the journalist doesn’t put it into context. We want to learn why Ottawa spent such a sum to prevent youth crime. This article let us think that juvenile crime is a society issue because it’s growing. This is the perfect example of the perception of a problem built by media. This other article about Youth crime and flawed statistics is a better example of this statement. To go further about this idea, click there.

However, this report shows us that a graph should never be the only source of a story. Here, we have a report issued by police divisions in British Columbia. If it’s a little bit old, we can see that to explain a problem entirely, we need a lot of figures, of graphs, of data, definitions and info. For example, with my graph, we see that juvenile delinquency is not growing, but I should have compared it with maybe other countries’ figures, or with policeman interviews etc to put into prospectives the figures I have found.

Picture 1

My first example will be the Campaign Finance graphic issued by the New York Times during 2008 campaign. This article shows us the financial data of 2008 campaign.

We can see receipts and expenses of each candidate. The graph is really comprehensive and detailed, and there is a lot of figures presented. The good thing is that when we open the page, firstly we see a very simple and clear table. But the big problem is that we don’t know what mean the figure. We have to click on it to see more details. And I’d have done it differently. Instead of putting the total receipts on the first page, I’d have put the total spent. I think it’s more newsworthy.

When we click on a candidate name to see more details, we open a map. Here again, it’s very understandable. We can easliy distinguish what areas made the better receipts. The little application at the bottom of the map shows us the chronology of the receipts. The flash is really well done, but I think it is useless for the common audience. I mean it can be very useful for an expert or people keen on campaign finances, but for common readers, it’s too much.

And then, when we click on “details”, next to the map, we have access to the exacts amounts. It’s very well presented. And the little graph near each amount enables us to see who did the best figure.

To sum up, we can say that this graph is very well documented, it shows a lot of interesting figures, but may be too much. And the lack of written explanation lead the common reader to be quickly lost among a lot of figures.

I don’t know which tool is used here, and the NYT doesn’tanswer my questions. But I guess the tool the journalist used is really complete, because it allows to make maps, tables and graphs.

Picture 2

The second article I want to comment is “The Hole in Manhattan” issued by the Washington Post. The journalist want to show us how many towers have been built meanwhile the project to rebuilt the World Trade Center have to face a lot of obstacles.

The graph is really well done, because we can see the progression of other buildings in the world, and we can click on some dates to see how the World Trade Center project progresses. And I find the theme deeply newsworthy.

But I consider that the graphs are not necessary. We have a lot of data about other towers we didn’t even know, and what really interest us, that is to say the World Trade Center, is finally poorly documented.

The good point is that there is a little presentation and a little soundslide to situate the issue. Contrary to the first example, here, we really know what we are talking about, and why. The data are really easy to interpret, for common people as for experts.

To sum up we can say that this graph have a really good presentation, it’s not too elaborate, and accessible to everyone. The problem is, to my point of view, that the graph is useless. A little text saying may be how many towers have been built during the elaboration of the project would have been sufficient, whereas a graph showing only the progression of the World Trade Center project would have been more interesting.

Concerning the tools used by the journalists, it’s written at the bottom of the graph that the sources are Skyscraperpage, but I don’t know if they only took their data there, or if they used the website to plot a graph. Anyway they didn’t use only this website, and I guess that for the presentation they used something like Adobe flash player.

A New Iranian Nuclear Program

44413407_p

The disclosure of a previously unacknowledged uranium enrichment facility in Iran broke the news this Friday in Pittsburgh, and overshadowed the G20 Summit. Barack Obama, Nicolas Sarkozy and Gordon Brown appeared side by side in front of the reporters saying that this program “represents a direct challenge to the basic foundation of the nonproliferation regime”.

AFP

AFP

Obama warned the Islamic Republic of Iran about the consequences the country could undergo if it don’t stop its nuclear program. France and UK went one step further giving Iran two months to comply with international laws or face “severe sanctions”. “We cannot let the Iranian leaders gain time while the motors are running. If by December there is not an in-depth change by the Iranian leaders, sanctions will have to be taken”, Sarkozy promised.

As a matter of facts, Iran, US, France, Russia, UK, China and Germany will meet the 1st of October, in Bruxelles, Belgium, to discuss Iran Nuclear Program. “So I think Iran is on notice that when we meet with them on October 1st Obama declared, “ they are going to have to come clean ”. And if Iran don’t want to “continue down a path that is going to lead to confrontation”, they have to stop “ the acquisition of nuclear weapons”. Gordon Brown added that “On October the first, Iran must now engage in the International Community, and join the International Community as a partner”.

Indeed, this new enrichment site, located near to Qom, is believed to be part of Iran’s effort to build nuclear weapons. Barack Obama judged the program incompatible with a civil goal of producing electricity. If the Qom plant is not yet operational, according to the Washington Post, it “and will be capable within months of producing enough material for at least one bomb per year.”.

qum_190_238

But, according to the New York Times, Iran told the agency “the new plant would enrich uranium to a level of 5 percent ― high enough for nuclear fuel, but not nearly enough to make the fissile material for an atomic bomb.”

Accusing Iran to break “rules that all nations must follow”, the three leaders asked International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) an “exhaustive, strict, and rigorous investigation” and required of Iran to cooperate and to open its second nuclear plant to the IAEA.

The IAEA announced Friday that Iran informed the agency about this new uranium enrichment plant by a letter the 21st of September. But a Fench official reveals that France, England and US became aware of suspicious work a few years ago. In this connection, President Ahmadinejad maintained that this second nuclear plant “wasn’t a secret”.

Besides, the President of Iran later said to the Washington Post that the IAEA can inspect the uranium enrichment plant. “We don’t have any problems with [IAEA] inspections of the facility,” he said. “ We have no fears”.

To see some videos of the conference, please click there.

Older Posts »